Table of Contents

Savings Account Interest Rates vs. Chit Fund Returns: What Works Best?

savings vs chit returns

Have you ever found yourself relaxing on your bed, catching up on Instagram, and you spot yet another post of someone buying their dream car, booking a vacation to the Maldives, or moving into a new home? Meanwhile, you’re left wondering: Where does all my money go?

It’s a frustrating feeling, isn’t it? Especially when you’ve been saving every rupee—from your piggy bank days to modern savings accounts. So, where did things go wrong? While everyone else seems to be effortlessly growing their money, here you are, working hard but still struggling to make more. The key here is, when it comes to managing your money wisely, the first question you need to ask yourself is: “Where should I save my hard-earned money?”

When it comes to saving your hard-earned money, bank accounts are the most common options that come to mind. They offer safety, liquidity, and modest savings account interest rates. Yet, with inflation climbing faster than ever, relying solely on a bank account could mean your money isn’t working hard enough for you.

Let’s dive deeper. The average savings account interest rate in India hovers around 3-4% per annum. If inflation is at 6%, the purchasing power of your money is actually decreasing over time. Now, what if there was a way for not just savings but also growing your money at a faster pace? That’s where alternative savings options like chit funds come in, offering potentially higher returns while supporting your financial goals.

So, the big question is: Savings account or chit fund—which is the smarter choice for savings and financial growth? Let’s compare these two to find the best fit for your goals.

The Basics and Beyond of Bank Account

A savings account is a secure place to park your money while earning a little extra in the form of savings account interest. Banks offer these accounts to help you save systematically while giving you quick access to your funds whenever needed.

Why Savings Accounts Are Popular

The beauty of a bank account lies in its simplicity and accessibility. Here are some standout benefits:

1. Liquidity:

Need cash quickly? A bank account lets you withdraw funds anytime, either through ATMs, online banking, or even a visit to the branch.

2. Safety:

With insurance coverage of up to ₹5,00,000 by the Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC), your deposits are protected, giving you peace of mind.

3. Savings Growth:

Though modest, the savings account interest rates offered by banks ensure your money grows steadily. For instance, many banks offer rates between 3-4% annually.

The Flip Side of Savings Account

However, let’s be real—bank accounts have their downsides too:

1. Low Returns:

With average savings account interest rates often trailing inflation, your purchasing power might decrease over time.

2. Limited Growth Potential

A bank account is great for short-term investment and savings goals but not for achieving long-term investment goals like retirement or wealth building.

savings account drawback

Chit Funds: Save and Borrow with Ease

If a bank account is your safety net, a chit fund is like a financial multi-tool offering both the discipline of savings and the flexibility of borrowing when you need it most. The dual nature of these savings plans makes them incredibly versatile.

Top Reasons to Choose Chit Funds

Savings & Borrowing in One:

If you don’t need the money immediately, your monthly contributions build your savings. But if you do, you can borrow the pooled savings amount for your financial needs.

Higher Returns:

Unlike the modest savings account interest rates, investment pools can offer better value through dividends distributed among members.

Flexibility:

Need funds for a medical emergency, a wedding, or a business investment? They provide a hassle-free way to access lump sums without the paperwork of a loan.

Savings Account Interest Rates vs. Chit Fund Returns

Let’s compare the savings account interest rates (typically 2–4% per annum) with the potential returns offered by chit funds, which often exceed these rates due to dividends.

Scenario 1: Savings Account

Imagine that you are depositing ₹10,000 each month into a bank account offering a savings account interest rate of 4% per annum for 10 months. The total balance in the would be approximately ₹1,01,513.41. This includes both the principal amount of ₹1,00,000 and the accrued interest [on the savings] of ₹1,513.41. Which means your profit is ₹1,513.41.

  • Monthly deposit: 10,000
  • Time Tenure: 10 months
  • After 10 months you will get:  ₹1,01,513.41
  • Interest Earned = ₹1,01,513.41 – ₹1,00,000 = ₹1,513.41

Scenario 2: Chit Funds

You join a ₹1,00,000 Fixed Dividend Chit Fund scheme with 10 members participating. As it is a fixed dividend chit each member will receive assured dividends and so would pay less than ₹10,000.  Here’s how the returns could work:

  • Total chit value: 1,00,000
  • Monthly Contribution: 89,050
  • After 10 months you will get: 95,000
  • Profit Earned: 6,000

Chit Funds vs. Savings Accounts: A Comparative Profit Analysis

1. Profit Earned:

  • In the bank account, the profit is ₹1,513.41, driven solely by a low annual interest rate over a short tenure.
  • In the chit fund, the profit is ₹6,000, significantly higher due to the fixed dividends reducing the monthly contribution amount.

2. Mode of Returns:

  • A bank account relies on compounding interest over time. The returns grow with tenure but remain relatively low for short durations.
  • Chit funds provide assured dividends and a higher immediate return on investment, especially with a fixed dividend model.

3. Investment Efficiency:

  • In the bank account, you contribute ₹1,00,000 to earn ₹1,513.41, which is less than 2% growth.
  • In the chit fund, you contribute approximately ₹89,050, yet receive ₹95,000, yielding a higher profit margin in the same period.

Advantages of Chit Funds Over Savings Accounts

1. Higher ROI for Short Term:

Investment pools are one of the financial instruments that are designed to offer tangible returns on savings within a shorter period, making them attractive for those seeking immediate financial gains on their savings.

2. Assured Returns: Where Savings Accounts Fall Short

The interest rates of bank accounts often hover between 3–4% annually. Add inflation to the mix, and your “savings” may actually lose value over time. Chit funds, on the other hand, provide dividends, for the savings, that can significantly boost your returns.

3. Borrowing Option: Savings Accounts Can’t Compete

Need urgent funds? Bank accounts can limit withdrawals or impose penalties. With chit funds, you can bid for the money you need without restrictions or affecting your savings. Simple, flexible, and penalty-free savings.

4. Community Benefit

Your savings contributions help other members achieve their financial goals, fostering collective savings growth while ensuring your returns on your savings are fixed.

4. Customized Plans

Bank accounts often fall short when it comes to catering to individual savings goals. With fixed interest rates and limited options for customization, they lack the flexibility needed for personalized financial planning. Chit funds, on the other hand, empower you to align your savings strategy with your unique personal finance objectives—whether it’s buying a car, funding your child’s education, or starting a business. This adaptability makes chit funds an excellent choice for those seeking tailored solutions to meet their financial aspirations.

Who Can Benefit the Most from Chit Funds

Investment pools are more than just a savings tool—they’re a lifeline for those seeking smarter financial solutions, but they truly shine for:

1. Small Business Owners Seeking Capital

Running a small bakery and need funds to expand? While a bank account is a safe place to park money, its growth depends on savings account interest rates, which are typically low (around 3-4% annually). Chits, however, provide quick access to lump sums, that is your savings. They provide a structured way to save while offering access to lump-sum amounts through auctions.

2. Families Saving for Milestones

Think about the big expenses in life—your child’s education, a wedding, or even a dream vacation. Families often rely on a savings account as their preferred choice. While it’s risk-free, the savings account interest adds up slowly, especially for short-term goals. In contrast, investment pools let you save regularly while offering higher returns and flexibility. Imagine saving ₹5,000 monthly in a chit scheme. By the end of the tenure, you could earn dividends and have access to a lump sum—far outpacing what you’d earn in a savings account.

3. Individuals Building Disciplined Saving Habits

Saving consistently is tough. But the investment pool makes it almost automatic. Unlike a savings account, where the temptation to withdraw is strong, community funds lock in your contributions, ensuring you stick to your savings plan.

Why Not Just Stick to a Savings Account?

Here’s the truth: Savings accounts are excellent for liquidity, but their growth potential is limited by savings account interest rates, which often fail to beat inflation. The flexible savings plan uniquely blends disciplined savings with the potential for higher returns.

savings account vs chit fund

Addressing Common Misconceptions About Chit Funds

Rotating Savings Schemes often spark curiosity, but let’s face it—there are some misconceptions floating around. Are they safe? Are they transparent? Let’s clear the air and see how regulated community funds stand tall as a reliable savings option.

Myth #1: Chit Funds Aren’t Safe

It’s a common concern, but here’s the truth: regulated funds operate under strict guidelines laid out by the Chit Funds Act, 1982. Companies are legally bound to follow these rules, ensuring transparency and investor safety.

Unlike the unpredictable returns of a savings account tied to fluctuating savings account interest rates, community savings offer a structured system where your contributions are safeguarded by regular audits and government oversight.

Myth #2: Chit Funds Are Riskier Than Savings Accounts

These accounts are undoubtedly secure, but their growth is slow, thanks to savings account interest rates averaging just 3-4% annually. Community savings, however, combine disciplined savings with the potential for higher returns through dividends.

Myth #3: Chit Funds Lack Transparency

Transparency is the backbone of regulated collective savings funds. Regulated companies ensure every participant knows the rules, auction process, and returns in advance. Detailed records are maintained, and every transaction is monitored. A savings account—while safe, many customers are unaware of the impact of savings account interest on long-term growth, often leaving their funds stagnant.

Actionable Tips to Get Started with Chit Funds

  • Conduct thorough research and select a well-established and reputable company.
  • Familiarize yourself with the rules and details of the chit scheme.
  • Start with a small contribution to get comfortable with the process.

Chit Funds: A Smarter Alternative

Why let your money sit idle in a bank account earning minimal interest? Take control of your financial future by exploring regulated investment pools. These offer flexibility, higher returns, and the chance to access lump-sum funds when you need them most.

Share your views in the comments section!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill the Form

We are happy to assist you!

Powered by Kopuram Chits Private Limited